{ "retrieved": "2026-10-07", "judges": [ { "judge_id": "2026-1652", "name_listing": "Morse Jr., James B.", "name_reported": "James B. Morse Jr.", "court_reported": "Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One", "assignment_listing": "Appeals Div. I", "date_appointment_reported": "November 6, 2017", "serving_since_listing": "2017", "commission_finding_reported": "Meets Judicial Performance Standards", "commission_meets_votes": "", "commission_does_not_meet_votes": "", "in_state_publicity_pamphlet_maricopa_scope": "True", "in_county_candidates_on_ballot_pdf": "", "county_list_applicable": "False", "report_url": "https://jpr.azcourts.gov/portals/2/148/jpr_reports/2026/2026-1652.pdf", "bio_url": "https://coa1.azcourts.gov/Court-Information/Judges/James-B-Morse", "pdf_page_count": "11" } ], "cohorts": [ { "cohort_id": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "judge_id": "2026-1652", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "scale_id": "legacy_5point", "survey_period_raw": "users from 06/2023 - 01/2025", "survey_start_month": "06/2023", "survey_end_month": "01/2025", "total_surveys_reported_values": "[37]", "source_pages": "[5, 6]" }, { "cohort_id": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "judge_id": "2026-1652", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "scale_id": "new_5point", "survey_period_raw": "users from 02/2025-09/2025", "survey_start_month": "02/2025", "survey_end_month": "09/2025", "total_surveys_reported_values": "[24]", "source_pages": "[8, 9, 10, 11]" } ], "questions": [ { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Legal reasoning ability", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Knowledge of law", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Decisions based on law and facts", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Clearly written, legally supported decisions", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__basic_fairness_and_impartiality", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Basic fairness and impartiality", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_race", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of race", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_gender", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of gender", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_religion", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of religion", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_national_origin", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of national origin", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_disability", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of disability", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_age", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of age", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_sexual_orientation", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of sexual orientation", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_economic_status", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Equal treatment regardless of economic status", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__written_decision_free_from_personal_bias", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Written decision free from personal bias", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Attentiveness", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Demeanor in communications with counsel", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Appropriate restrictions on counsel during argument", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Relevant questions", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Preparation for oral argument", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Clear and logical communications", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Understanding and compassion", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Dignified", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Courteous", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Patient", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Conduct that promotes public confidence in the court", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Punctual in conducting proceedings", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Maintains proper control over courtroom", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Prepared for proceedings", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Respectful treatment of staff", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Cooperation with peers", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Cooperation with staff", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Efficient management of calendar", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Promptness in making rulings and rendering decisions", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Works effectively with other judges", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_court_personnel", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Works effectively with other court personnel", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "instrument_id": "appellate_legacy_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Effective handling of ongoing workload", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Legal reasoning ability", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Knowledge of law", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Decisions based on law and facts", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section I: Legal Ability", "question_label_reported": "Clearly written, legally supported decisions", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_ii_integrity__unbiased_and_impartial", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section II: Integrity", "question_label_reported": "Unbiased and impartial", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Attentiveness", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Demeanor in communications with counsel", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Appropriate restrictions on counsel during argument", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Relevant questions", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Preparation for oral argument", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section III: Communication Skills", "question_label_reported": "Clear and logical communications", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Understanding and compassion", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Conduct that promotes public confidence in the court", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__respectful_to_all_individuals", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Respectful to all individuals", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Dignified", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Courteous", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section IV: Judicial temperament", "question_label_reported": "Patient", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Punctual in conducting proceedings", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Maintains proper control over courtroom", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Prepared for proceedings", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Respectful treatment of staff", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Cooperation with peers", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Cooperation with staff", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Efficient management of calendar", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Works effectively with other judges", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Effective handling of ongoing workload", "row_type": "question" }, { "question_id": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "instrument_id": "appellate_new_5point", "section_label_reported": "Section V: Administrative Performance", "question_label_reported": "Promptness in making rulings and rendering decisions", "row_type": "question" } ], "results": [ { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.6, "n": 14.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 10.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.4, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 11.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.6, "n": 14.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 10.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.4, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 11.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.5, "n": 14.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 10.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.5, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 12.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.6, "n": 14.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 10.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.5, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 11.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__basic_fairness_and_impartiality", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 13.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 11.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__basic_fairness_and_impartiality", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__basic_fairness_and_impartiality", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.6, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 12.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_race", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 9.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 7.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_race", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_race", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_gender", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 10.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 8.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_gender", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_gender", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_religion", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 9.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 7.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_religion", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_religion", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_national_origin", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 9.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 7.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_national_origin", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_national_origin", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_disability", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 9.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 7.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_disability", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_disability", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_age", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 10.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 8.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_age", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_age", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_sexual_orientation", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 9.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 7.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_sexual_orientation", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_sexual_orientation", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_economic_status", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.8, "n": 10.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 8.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_economic_status", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__equal_treatment_regardless_of_economic_status", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__written_decision_free_from_personal_bias", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__written_decision_free_from_personal_bias", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_ii_integrity__written_decision_free_from_personal_bias", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.6, "n": 15.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 12.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.7, "n": 7.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 5.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.5, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 3.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": 0.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 0.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.3, "n": 7.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 4.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.2, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 3.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.7, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 4.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 3.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 0.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.7, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 4.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 3.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 0.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.7, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 4.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 3.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 0.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.2, "n": 6.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 2.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 3.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 3.2, "n": 13.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": 5.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 1.0, "VP": null, "SU": 6.0, "SA": 1.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 3.5, "n": 13.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 11.0, "SA": 1.0, "UN": 1.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_court_personnel", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_court_personnel", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 3.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 0.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_court_personnel", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [ "Multiple numeric values appear in this group header; extra values are preserved without assigning an unprinted label." ], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 5, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 0.0, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": 0.0, "VP": null, "SU": 1.0, "SA": 0.0, "UN": 0.0 } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_legacy_5point__06_2023_01_2025", "question": "appellate_legacy_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 5, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 4.8, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_ii_integrity__unbiased_and_impartial", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_ii_integrity__unbiased_and_impartial", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 5.0, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 14.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_ii_integrity__unbiased_and_impartial", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 5.0, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 14.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 13.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 12.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 12.0, "GD": 2.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 12.0, "GD": 2.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__respectful_to_all_individuals", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__respectful_to_all_individuals", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.8, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 12.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 1.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__respectful_to_all_individuals", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.8, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 12.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 1.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.7, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 11.0, "GD": 2.0, "AC": 1.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.6, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 10.0, "GD": 3.0, "AC": 1.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 5.0, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 14.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "attorneys", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 5.0, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 14.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 8, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "attorneys", "mean": 5.0, "n": 3.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "judicial_peers", "mean": 4.9, "n": 14.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 13.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "superior_court_judges", "mean": 4.8, "n": 4.0, "page": 8, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": 1.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__legal_reasoning_ability", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__knowledge_of_law", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__decisions_based_on_law_and_facts", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_i_legal_ability__clearly_written_legally_supported_decisions", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_ii_integrity__unbiased_and_impartial", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__attentiveness", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__demeanor_in_communications_with_counsel", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__appropriate_restrictions_on_counsel_during_argument", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 3.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 3.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__relevant_questions", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__preparation_for_oral_argument", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iii_communication_skills__clear_and_logical_communications", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__understanding_and_compassion", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__conduct_that_promotes_public_confidence_in_the_court", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__respectful_to_all_individuals", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 4.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [ "Question valid n exceeds the visible group header count; use question n, not header n, and retain source discrepancy." ], "counts": { "VG": 4.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__dignified", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__courteous", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_iv_judicial_temperament__patient", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": 5.0, "n": 1.0, "page": 9, "status": "reported", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": 1.0, "GD": 0.0, "AC": 0.0, "PO": 0.0, "VP": 0.0, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__punctual_in_conducting_proceedings", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__maintains_proper_control_over_courtroom", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__prepared_for_proceedings", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__respectful_treatment_of_staff", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_peers", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__cooperation_with_staff", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__efficient_management_of_calendar", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__works_effectively_with_other_judges", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__effective_handling_of_ongoing_workload", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } }, { "judge": "2026-1652", "cohort": "2026-1652__appellate_new_5point__02_2025_09_2025", "question": "appellate_new_5point__section_v_administrative_performance__promptness_in_making_rulings_and_rendering_decisions", "group": "oral_argument_table_group", "mean": null, "n": null, "page": 9, "status": "blank_in_source", "warnings": [], "counts": { "VG": null, "GD": null, "AC": null, "PO": null, "VP": null, "SU": null, "SA": null, "UN": null } } ], "scales": [ { "scale_id": "new_5point", "display_order": [ "VG", "GD", "AC", "PO", "VP" ], "values": [ { "code": "VG", "label": "Very Good", "numeric_value": 5 }, { "code": "GD", "label": "Good", "numeric_value": 4 }, { "code": "AC", "label": "Acceptable", "numeric_value": 3 }, { "code": "PO", "label": "Poor", "numeric_value": 2 }, { "code": "VP", "label": "Very Poor", "numeric_value": 1 } ] }, { "scale_id": "legacy_5point", "display_order": [ "SU", "VG", "SA", "PO", "UN" ], "values": [ { "code": "SU", "label": "Superior", "numeric_value": 4 }, { "code": "VG", "label": "Very Good", "numeric_value": 3 }, { "code": "SA", "label": "Satisfactory", "numeric_value": 2 }, { "code": "PO", "label": "Poor", "numeric_value": 1 }, { "code": "UN", "label": "Unacceptable", "numeric_value": 0 } ] } ] }